MKVToolNix vs HandBrake: remux or re encode?
MKVToolNix vs HandBrake is not a contest between two similar programs. One rearranges streams inside a container without touching them; the other re encodes video into a new, usually smaller file. Which one you need depends on the job.
Updated By Remux Ledger
Key facts
- MKVToolNix job: Remux, no re encoding
- HandBrake job: Transcode to MP4, MKV or WebM
- Quality: Unchanged vs new encode
- Speed: Disk bound vs CPU or GPU bound
- Price: Both free
- Checked:
Use MKVToolNix when you want to add, remove or relabel tracks in an MKV without changing quality, and HandBrake when you want a smaller file, a different codec or MP4 output. MKVToolNix copies streams, so it is fast and lossless; HandBrake decodes and re encodes, which takes longer and changes the picture. Many people use both.
MKVToolNix vs HandBrake: the core difference
In the MKVToolNix vs HandBrake question the deciding word is re encoding. The Matroska toolkit never decodes video or audio; it takes the existing streams and writes them into a new container with the tracks, flags and metadata you choose. The output is bit for bit the same picture and sound as the input.
HandBrake's documentation describes it as an open source video transcoder that converts video from supported sources into MP4 or MKV. Transcoding means decoding every frame and compressing it again with new settings. That is how you shrink a Blu-ray rip or make a file that an old phone can play, and it always costs time and some quality.
Side by side
| MKVToolNix | HandBrake | |
|---|---|---|
| Main purpose | Edit container contents | Convert and compress video |
| Re encodes video | No | Yes |
| Quality change | None | Depends on encoder settings |
| Output | MKV, WebM | MP4, MKV, WebM |
| Speed | Limited by disk | Limited by CPU or GPU |
| Remove or reorder tracks | Yes | Yes, during a re encode |
| Edit title or language in place | Yes, Header editor | No |
| Chapter editor | Yes | Chapter names only |
| Command line | mkvmerge and others | HandBrakeCLI |
| Price | Free | Free |
When to use the Matroska toolkit
- Drop a language or commentary track from a film you already like the quality of.
- Add an external SRT or ASS subtitle file to a video.
- Fix the title, track names or default language.
- Join episodes or split a long recording at keyframes.
- Extract a subtitle or audio track to a separate file.
The walkthrough on removing audio and subtitle tracks shows the first case step by step.
When to use HandBrake
- Make a large file smaller.
- Convert HEVC or another codec to H.264 for an older device.
- Produce MP4 for a TV or phone that does not play MKV.
- Burn subtitles into the picture.
- Apply filters such as deinterlacing or cropping.
Using both together
A common workflow is to re encode the video once in HandBrake and then use the Matroska toolkit to assemble the final file: put the new video together with the original lossless audio, all subtitle tracks, chapters and fonts, and set the default flags. Because the second step is a remux, it adds no further quality loss.
If neither fits, for example because you need lossless MP4 output or frame accurate cuts, the list of alternatives covers FFmpeg, LosslessCut and others. The full review has more on what the Matroska suite can and cannot do.
FAQ
Is MKVToolNix better than HandBrake?
They do different jobs. The Matroska toolkit edits what is inside an MKV without quality loss; HandBrake re encodes video to change size, codec or format.
Can MKVToolNix compress video like HandBrake?
No. It never re encodes, so it cannot reduce the bitrate of a video stream. The only way it makes a file smaller is by removing tracks.
Can HandBrake remove subtitles without re encoding?
No. HandBrake always transcodes the video. To drop a track and keep the original quality, a remux tool is the right choice.
Are both free?
Yes. Both are free, open source programs for Windows, macOS and Linux.
Which one is faster?
A remux is usually much faster, because it only reads and writes data. Transcoding speed depends on the processor or graphics card and the encoder settings.